FERAL: Foundation for Ecological Research, Advocacy and Learning

Foundation for Ecological Research, Advocacy and Learning

Navigating customary law and state fishing legislation to create effective fisheries governance in India

TitleNavigating customary law and state fishing legislation to create effective fisheries governance in India
Publication TypeJournal Article
Year of Publication2017
AuthorsKarnad, D
JournalMarine Policy
Volume86
Pagination 241-246
Date Published12/2017
KeywordsArtisanal fishing, Co-management, Customary tenure, Fishing conflicts, Legal pluralism, Maharashtra, Small-scale fishing
Abstract

When customary legal systems exist alongside state regulations, individuals can choose between these different frameworks to support their claims to resources. Research suggests that such framework switching to maximize self-interest weakens and challenges resource management. Multiple legal systems are at work in India's fisheries and this study examines how they work to govern conflict over purse-seine fishing in the Sindhudurg district of Maharashtra State. Through participant observations, interviews and state fishing law reviews, this study finds evidence of strong customary legal systems, operating through local cultural practices, to protect common property rights, equitable access, ethical and ecological concerns. In contrast, state legislation appears weak because it addresses issues of local concern, such as equitable access, at a slow pace and over such a large scale as to be absent. Consequently, multiple legal systems in these fisheries do not create a management challenge that follows a predictable path towards resource degradation. Instead informal, customary rules applied alongside formal state legislation interact in complex ways that create opportunities for effective co-management.

URLhttp://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0308597X17304396
Programme
.
FERAL - once wild, runs wild again.